Jump to content

Skkipper

Members
  • Posts

    2,145
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Skkipper

  1. No I bring what is fun for me. Hell I finished last at tsfht in January as I brought khorne walkers.

    Fluger I am good friends with solid gt players and they never chipmunked scores. These are the guys from Toledo. Some players probably did but not the good players

  2. The facts are player scored comp helps balance a unbalanced game. When was the last event that had no rules on other than points limit on what you can bring? There are no or very few unbound or limitless detachment events. Opponent scored comp is a poll on what you brought

  3. That sure does sound like fun. I love arbitrary popularity contest treadmilling and backbiting, it's what makes high school such a delightful time! Tell me, is there also a way that we can add a system to tournaments that encourages cliques and social ostracization as well? Perhaps some sort of official policy to call up attendees and shame them in front of everyone present? I really think it would encourage the growth of the hobby if we were a bit more petty and self-destructive in our habits.

    We already have sportsmanship and I openly score my opponent so they know what I thought of the game. I know you Portland people are sensitive but a comp score by your opponent is the best. The passive aggressive PNW this may cause hurt feelings but if you take a jerkbutt list. Your opponent should be able to mark you down.

  4. I think the comp scores worked well back in 2nd 3rd and 4th editions. It really made people not take obvious i am a jerk lists. I still did. I put together a 888 point 8 man khorne chosen on bikes unit in chaos 3.5. It was tough and I got would get dinged on comp points but it was fun to play.

    • Like 1
  5. The power levels between books are so huge. It can't be balanced. We just need to punish players who take power lists. That is what old comp scores did. You could win all your games yet not win anything at an event.

  6. 40k has never been balanced. We could just go back to giving an army 0-10 points on comp by the players playing against it. the problem is too many players get all hurt if there opponent gives them a zero then play their friend with a cheese list and gives him a ten.

  7. You are wrong pretre. As soon as you take a third troop choice you are paying the tax on necrons. I haven't looked at new eldar book but it prevents the swarm of 6 units of scatbikes. I feel spamming the same unit over and over is the most painful thing at events. Beat my pants off fine, just don't do it with min/max spam.

  8. Basically spamming is where stuff gets broken. If we just paid a points tax on each duplicate unit. List would become less spammy

     

    1st unit is free

    2nd is 25% tax

    3rd unit is 50% tax

    .

    .

    .

    I feel a system like that doesn't prevent people from taking themed lists. It makes the game more diverse.

  9. Ork horde

    Zhadsnark 'Da Rippa' 150

    Warboss: Da Lucky Stikk; power klaw; warbike 135

    Painboy: grot orderly; warbike 80

     

    14 Warbikerz: Boss Nob (power klaw) 287

    3 Warbikerz 54

    3 Warbikerz 54

    3 Warbikerz 54

     

    Great Waaagh!

    Big Mek: Mega Force Field; killsaw; warbike 165

    Warboss: Big Bosspole; power klaw; warbike 130

     

    10 Gretchin: + 1 Runtherd 35

    10 Gretchin: + 1 Runtherd 35

     

    8 Tankbustas 104

    • Trukk 30

    8 Tankbustas 104

    • Trukk 30

    8 Tankbustas 104

    • Trukk 30

    8 Tankbustas 104

    • Trukk 30

    8 Tankbustas 104

    • Trukk 30

     

    1,849 points

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...