IMHO The hulk wins this matchup if it comes down to a slugfest in overtime . The Hulk has an unlimited potential for strength "the angrier he gets the stronger he gets". The Hulk does not get winded or get tired but Superman does. Superman depends on solar radiation and lack of Kryptonian chemicals in the area, the Hulk relies on rage.
The fight probably goes down something like this. I think in the short term Superman notices that the Hulk is intent on property damage and a desire to be left alone. Superman being no fool lets the green machine wonder off and become Banner. Thus Superman wins using "The Art of War". He seeks to know his enemy. By knowing his enemy he sees that his enemy is overconfident in his strength. In knowing this weakness Superman "feigns" defeat by leaving the field of battle which ends the fight. The Hulk believes he has won and for all intents and purposes he has. Superman on the other hand prefers peaceful resolution with minimal harm to participants and witnesses. In this matchup Supermans' apparent loss is actually his victory.