Based on @evil_bryan 's recommendation i tried using eSun PLA+ for a while. I then switched back to Hatchbox PLA. I'll be switching back to eSun PLA+
I won't be using anyone's black filament ever again. I have horrible nozzle clogging problems and adhesion issues. I've tried many different temps, flow, settings etc and I hate it. Nothing anyone will say here will get me to use it again. I gave my 1/2 full spool away. I know it's weird, but there it is.
I don't know if it's the composition or the manufacturer but I get better consistency with the eSun PLA+ in Grey.
I get horrible stringing with the Hatchbox PLA, again in grey, but even that's all over the place. On one print it's fine, on a different one with the same settings I go fuzzy.
Hatchbox PLA white seems to be a bit more stable, but again it's not consistent.
It's not an exhaustive test set, as I'm way more interested in printing for my hobby, rather than printing as my hobby. I just want to find what works for me and stick with it.
So, back to the eSun.
Would clear PLA+ be even more consistent? Less additives?