Jump to content

peter.cosgrove

Members
  • Posts

    1,012
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Posts posted by peter.cosgrove

  1. Well, there is a right way of doing things like this, and the wrong way. What's going on here is the wrong way.

    The right way of doing this is to have a player's meeting prior to the first round, when all the player's are available and have a say, have a consensus vote, make sure all player's are aware of the rule and inspect players that have lists affected by the rule to ensure they have the ruleset on-hand, either hard-copy or electronically.

  2. You have adequately pointed out a failure on my part, to wit, specifically pointing out a cut off date for the event. The fact of the matter is, the world has changed and I appreciate the rather extreme levels of responsiveness currently observable from Games Workshop and would prefer to not limit players from bringing their experiences and pleasure in the game to an event that I wish to run.

    But there has to be an acceptable standard and I am drawing that line at the GW FAQ/Errata webpage. Bear in mind, if the webpage gets updated prior to 10AM tomorrow and I can view the changes on the devices I am bringing tomorrow then I am fine with it. I just expended 80$ in printing to ensure that I have, on-site, every single document on that webpage. So if it's not in my binder by 1001 tomorrow morning it won't be in play.

    Actually, don't quote me on that, because I printed out both the bolter discipline and the forgeworld custodes rulesets for my binder to have on hand.

  3. I believe there is an assumption which is incorrect. Sisters of Battle have rulesets, multiple ones, contained in both indexes and chapter approved.

    I think you are getting fixated on the term Beta which I don't think has an application to the original query, as there is only two items that I am aware of currently in beta status.

    The Bolter Discipline is a proposed standalone rule across multiple codexes and indexes and hasn't yet been added by GW to the official up-to-date errata for those living documents. Whatever my personal feelings are regarding the appropriateness of the proposed rule, the fact that the living documents have not been amended makes the decision to not include them appropriate.

    In addition the ruleset for the Adeptus Custodes forgeworld models specifically states:

    "The datasheets presented here are in a beta format. As with all our
    beta rules, we would like to invite you, the players, to use them in
    your games and provide us with your feedback. What worked well?
    What could be improved? What points values should be changed
    (and to what)? Please get in touch with us at 40kfaq@gwplc.com
    and let us know (please make the subject of your e-mail ‘Beta
    Adeptus Custodes feedback’). This feedback will then help to inform
    the final rules for these units in a future publication.
    Whilst these beta rules have been designed to be used in all types
    of games, including matched play games, if you intend to use them
    at organised events then it is ultimately up to the event organiser as
    to whether these rules will be allowed or not (as is the case with all
    our beta rules)."

    The fact that the designers have not yet quantified a final balanced point value for these forgeworld models and have not amended the existing parent living documents makes, objectively, the decision to not include them appropriate.

  4. I am more objectively concerned with the GW webpage statement:

    Specifically:

    "Looking for the latest updates to your codex or battletome? Got a question about how something in your army works? Each of these FAQs contains all of the most up-to-date errata and answers you’ll need to make sure that your games run as smoothly as possible, incorporating feedback from you guys and gals out there in the Warhammer community, the playtesters and of course, our studio design team."

    Since neither the Bolter Discipline nor the Adeptus Custodes proposed rulesets are contained on this page I am uncomfortable including them. I apologize if this causes confusion or consternation.

  5. I have reconducted a review of the following:

    The requirement to upload army lists is not feasible for Guardian Cup 2019. There will be WiFi available, however I will only have 1 device available for players to register if they have not registered and those players will have priority.

    Games will be standard games with 2:30 minute rounds and a 30 minute TO Discretion/break between each game

    There will be some Enclosed Ruins on the tables so review the Enclosed Ruins rules below.

    There will be pizza available on Sat during the lunch break, I have ordered pepperoni and Hawaiian, as well as some donuts on Sun.

    ITC Code of Conduct:

    https://docs.google.com/document/d/1RFhFICnwr15wK0pdUcUnp0uNRn_-jUdtZvHKPTTR4Yo/edit

    ITC Terrain Guidelines:

    https://docs.google.com/document/d/1l6E-871Ob11iY2blqkxrJJzP8wLoKARaP5KfzlG9S9M/edit

    • Thanks 1
  6. The ruleset for Adeptus Custodes play will include the following official update 1.0:

    https://whc-cdn.games-workshop.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/warhammer_40000_adeptus_custodes_en.pdf

    As the beta rules in question here:

    https://whc-cdn.games-workshop.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Forgeworld_Custodes_Datasheets-1.pdf

    As well as the Bolter Discipline Beta here:

    https://www.warhammer-community.com/2019/01/21/21st-jan-introducing-better-beta-boltersgw-homepage-post-4/

    are not included and do not contain the term Official Update they will not be in play for this event.

     

     

    • Like 2
  7. We currently have 17 players registered for Guardian Cup 2019 through Best Coast Pairings at the following web page:

    https://www.bestcoastpairings.com/eventlanding/eqe2cppp?embed=false

    I am tracking 10 players who have conducted a pre-pay transaction

    The pre-pay tickets through the OF Store as well as conducting ticket sales onsite during the event is my personal responsibility. I will be bringing pre-pay player packets including receipts to the event and be responsible to the Ordo Fanaticus fiduciary for accounting of the pre-pay funds.

    Registration on the Best Coast Pairings event page before the event is the player responsibility, and I will have available a device or devices at the registration table for players to conduct registration at the event in the event that a player is unable to register prior to the event. 

    If you have questions or concerns contact me via email/pm or txt/vox 503-957-7906

    Peter Cosgrove
    Tournament Organizer
    Guardian Cup 2019

  8. It looks like, according to GW, the pre-orders are going to drop on or around Feb 8, and the codex will drop actual on or around Feb 16. As long as the GW product codex and datasheets are readily available and viewable on-site, either electronically or hardcopy, and the models are WYSIWYG with 3 paints and basing then yes. I don't see any reason to not allow them.

  9. Alrighty.

    Flyers have been posted

    Facebook entries have been made at Ordo Fanaticus, Guardian Games, and NW Wargamers.

    Tournament is posted at DakkaDakka

    Event Parking is coordinated 

    Prize Package plan is complete.

    Refined Paint/Sportsmanship to bring equalization.

    Tasks left to do.

    Player Packets

    Post Event Parking

    Post Prize Package Details

    Improve and refine.

    Develop occupation and registration flow plan, current coordination includes a 0900 hit time on Sat for set-up, an hour to complete set-up means crunch time before the 1000 doors open. need to backwards plan manpower requirements and tasking.

    Develop terrain quality plan, current intent is to requisition additional terrain from OF supply

    Finalize and post on-site payment plan

    Develop meal plan, current intent is for a Sat Pizza Party, and Sun Donuts.

    Develop Paint Judge plan, current intent is to adopt a pre-existing SOP and bring in an experienced paint judge to conduct the paint judging.

    Please, if you have suggestions to improve let me know, sooner is always better, this is still new boots for me.

     

    • Like 1
    • Thanks 1
×
×
  • Create New...