Fair question
We have discussed this, but feel that not everyone in the community would like to see this go away.
I think a good way to look at OFCC is:
Primary Objective: Have a great time
Secondary Objective: Be a good sport
Tertiary Objective: Win some games
Historically, we have promoted OFCC as "five great games." As an organization, we value sportsmanship above all else.
To speak to your concerns about evaluating a player and their list as a sportsmanship component, Joel and I had a lengthy discussion before this system was rolled out. Ordo as an organization must evaluate the player experience, as this correlates directly to our goals for the event. The methodology in separating the player from the list was to evaluate the opponent experience from the army match up. If we see negative responses to the willingness to play a person again, then event organizers will be following up to ensure there are no larger problems.